Rich Dad Says
Value investing isn’t dead — it’s just been hiding in plain sight while everyone chases shiny objects.
Let’s get one thing straight: value investing was never about low P/E ratios. That’s textbook nonsense. Real value investing is buying $1 for 50 cents — whether it’s a boring bank stock or a high-growth SaaS company temporarily misunderstood by the market. In 1999, people said value was dead because dot-com stocks were doubling every 3 months. Then the NASDAQ fell nearly 78% from 2000–2002. Suddenly, “boring” cash-flow businesses looked sexy again.
Growth stocks dominate when capital is cheap. From 2009 to 2021, interest rates hovered near 0%. When money costs nothing, investors pay 20x revenue for companies promising profits in 2035. But when rates rise — like in 2022 when the Fed hiked aggressively — those same growth darlings can drop 50–80%. Why? Because future earnings get discounted harder. Value isn’t dead — it’s cyclical.
Here’s the real twist: the best investors blend growth and value. Warren Buffett bought Apple — a “growth” stock — when it traded at around 15x earnings in 2016. That’s value thinking applied to a growth machine. Amazon in 2001 looked like a speculative tech bet. But if you understood its long-term cash flow potential, that was value. Tesla in 2019 at $40 (pre-split) looked absurdly risky — until it wasn’t.
The mistake amateurs make is confusing “cheap” with “valuable.” A declining retail chain trading at a P/E of 5 might be a value trap. Meanwhile, a company growing revenue 25% annually with expanding margins might be true value at 25x earnings. If a business compounds earnings at 20% per year, it doubles roughly every 3.5 years. Over 10 years, that’s nearly 6x growth. Paying a premium for that isn’t foolish — it’s strategic.
Counterpoint? Yes, pure deep value — cigar-butt investing — has underperformed growth over the last decade in many markets. But markets rotate. Energy stocks were ignored for years until 2022, when they outperformed the S&P 500 by double digits. Cycles don’t announce themselves — they punish consensus.
So is value investing dead? No. Lazy value investing is dead. Mechanical screening is dead. Intelligent capital allocation is alive and thriving.
If you want wealth, don’t argue growth vs. value. Ask: Is this asset producing increasing cash flow relative to what I’m paying? That’s it. That’s the game.
Value investing isn’t dead — bad analysis is.