Should I pay off debt or start investing first?

Question

Rich Dad · Accepted Answer

Debt isn’t the enemy — bad debt is.
Let’s get something straight: the question isn’t “debt or investing?” The question is what’s your interest rate and what’s your return rate? If your debt costs you 4% and your investments can realistically earn 10%, paying off that debt first is like refusing to buy a rental property because you still have a cheap mortgage. That’s small thinking.
Here’s how I look at it. If you have $20,000 in student loans at 5% interest, that’s costing you about $1,000 per year. But if that same $20,000 invested in a low-cost index fund averages 8–10% annually over 20 years, that money could grow to $93,000–$134,000. That’s the power of compounding working for you instead of against you. Killing the debt might feel good emotionally, but mathematically you could be sacrificing six figures.
Now — big caveat — if you’re carrying credit card debt at 18–25%, that’s financial cancer. No investment reliably beats 25% annually. Paying that off is a guaranteed 25% return. I’d wipe that out immediately. But a 3% car loan? A 4% mortgage? That’s cheap leverage. The wealthy use leverage strategically. Corporations borrow billions at 4–6% to invest in projects earning 12–15%. Why should you think smaller than a corporation?
There’s also opportunity cost. Let’s say you spend 3 years aggressively paying off $30,000 in low-interest debt instead of investing. That’s 3 years of missed market exposure. Historically, the S&P 500 averages about 10% annually. Miss just the 10 best market days over 20 years and your returns drop dramatically. Time in the market beats timing your debt payoff.
But here’s where nuance matters: cash flow and psychology. If your minimum payments are strangling your monthly budget, you’re not in a position to invest aggressively anyway. And if debt stresses you out so badly that you can’t sleep, your mental bandwidth is shot — and entrepreneurs need clear minds.
My strategy? Hybrid approach. Kill high-interest debt immediately. Keep low-interest debt. Simultaneously invest consistently — even if it’s just 10–20% of your income. Automate it. Build assets while managing liabilities. Don’t wait to be “debt-free” to start building wealth — that’s middle-class conditioning.
The rich focus on net worth growth, not emotional victories.
If your money can earn more than your debt costs, make it work — don’t tuck it in and let it sleep.

Poor Dad · Answer

If you owe money, you are not free — you are working for someone else.
Before you even think about investing, you must ask yourself a simple question: how will you feel if the market drops 30% while you still owe money? Because that happens. In 2008, the S&P 500 fell about 37% in one year. In 2020, it dropped over 30% in a matter of weeks. If you had invested instead of paying off debt, you would still owe every dollar — but your investments would be worth far less.
Paying off debt gives you something investing cannot guarantee: certainty. If you eliminate a 6% loan, that’s a guaranteed 6% return. No volatility. No sleepless nights. No headlines about recessions. Compare that to the stock market’s “average” 10% return — which includes brutal down years. Averages don’t pay your bills in a crisis.
Let’s talk about cash flow. Suppose you have $25,000 in loans with $600 monthly payments. Imagine eliminating that payment. That’s $7,200 per year freed up. You could then invest that full amount — without stress — every year going forward. In 15 years at 8% growth, that could become around $195,000. But now you’re investing from a position of strength, not obligation.
And consider job stability. If you lose your job tomorrow, debt becomes dangerous. During economic downturns, layoffs are common. In 2020 alone, millions lost employment in weeks. If you have no debt, your required monthly expenses are lower. That means your emergency fund lasts longer. That’s security. That’s breathing room.
Now, I will admit there’s nuance. If your mortgage rate is 3% and inflation is 4–5%, mathematically you may be better off investing. But life is not just math. It’s risk tolerance, job stability, and family responsibility. If you have children depending on you, stability should matter more than squeezing out an extra 2–3% return.
My advice? Build a 3–6 month emergency fund first. Then aggressively eliminate all non-mortgage debt. Once you are stable and secure, begin investing consistently for retirement — especially in tax-advantaged accounts like a 401(k) with employer match.
Peace of mind is underrated. Wealth built on a solid foundation lasts longer than wealth built on leverage.
Security first, growth second — because you can’t build wealth while standing on quicksand.

Should I pay off debt or start investing first?

Rich Dad Says

Poor Dad Says

The Bottom Line

Whose advice would you follow?

Share this debate

What do you think? (0)

More debates