Skip to content

The Dads Were Asked...

Should you buy into an IPO on day one or always wait and see?

7 months ago · 2,114 views · Updated Oct 22, 2026

AI-generated perspectives — for educational purposes only · How these are made · Not financial advice

The Bottom Line

Both perspectives agree that IPOs carry elevated risk, especially in the early days of hype and volatility. Rich Dad supports selective, well-sized participation with a long-term mindset, while Poor Dad favors waiting for financial data and price stabilization. Your decision should depend on your risk tolerance, time horizon, and whether you’re investing strategically or reacting emotionally.

No reader verdict yet — read both sides and cast your vote

IPOs attract massive attention and often surge in price during their first trading days, tempting investors to jump in immediately. Deciding whether to buy on day one or wait can significantly impact long-term returns and risk exposure. This choice can mean the difference between disciplined wealth-building and emotionally driven speculation.

Rich Dad Says

IPOs are like opening night at a blockbuster movie — the real money is made by the people who financed the film, not the ones buying popcorn.

Let’s get something straight: by the time you can buy on day one, the venture capitalists, founders, and institutional investors have already bought in at a fraction of the price. Snowflake priced its 2020 IPO at $120 and opened around $245 — so day-one buyers paid roughly double what institutions paid, and by mid-2022 the stock was trading at about half that opening price. Rivian debuted at $78, rocketed to $179 within days, and then fell below $30. The pattern? Day-one buyers often fund early investors’ exits. That’s not investing — that’s being liquidity.

Now, am I saying never buy an IPO early? No. I’m saying have a strategy, not FOMO. If you’re getting pre-IPO access at institutional pricing — different story. But if you’re buying after a 40–80% first-day spike, you’re gambling on momentum, not fundamentals. Studies show that, on average, IPOs underperform the broader market over 3–5 years after the initial pop. Why? Overvaluation, lock-up expirations (usually 90–180 days later), and hype fading into reality.

Here’s the smarter aggressive play: wait for the lock-up period to expire. Insiders can’t sell for about six months. When that window opens, supply floods the market and prices often dip. Facebook IPO’d at $38 in 2012, stumbled below $20 within months, and skeptics declared it dead. Those who bought during that pessimism saw it climb over $300 within a decade. Patience turned panic into profit.

But let’s not ignore opportunity cost. If the company is a category killer — think Google in 2004 or Amazon in 1997 — and fundamentals justify it, buying early and holding long-term can be powerful. The key is position sizing. Put 5–10% of your portfolio in high-conviction IPO plays, not 50%. Treat it like venture capital inside your public portfolio: high risk, asymmetric upside.

Counterargument? "But what if I miss the rocket ship?" Good. Missing one rocket won’t bankrupt you. Chasing every rocket might. Wealth isn’t built on excitement — it’s built on disciplined aggression. I’d rather buy a great company 30% off after hype fades than brag about getting in on day one and quietly bleed for two years.

So here’s the rule: If you’re buying because it’s trending, wait. If you’re buying because you understand the business deeply and can hold 5–10 years, size it smartly and go in with eyes open.

IPOs don’t make you rich — ownership over time does.

Poor Dad Says

If you feel pressure to buy something on its very first day, that’s usually a sign to slow down.

IPOs are exciting, heavily marketed, and often surrounded by media hype. But excitement and investing don’t mix well. Historically, many IPOs are priced aggressively to maximize what the company raises. Investment banks and insiders have strong incentives to set optimistic valuations. Research has shown that while IPOs may jump 10–20% on the first day, their average 3-year performance often trails the S&P 500. That should make any cautious investor pause.

Consider real examples. Facebook’s IPO in 2012 was widely anticipated, yet the stock fell nearly 50% within months. Rivian, as mentioned, soared above $170 shortly after debuting in 2021, only to drop more than 80% over the next year. Even highly respected companies like Uber went public in 2019 at $45 and traded below that price for over a year. If you had simply waited 6–12 months, you could often buy at a more reasonable valuation — with actual earnings reports to analyze.

Waiting gives you something incredibly valuable: information. After two or three quarterly earnings reports, you can examine revenue growth, margins, cash flow, and management guidance. You can compare price-to-earnings or price-to-sales ratios to industry peers. For example, if a company debuts at 25 times sales while competitors trade at 8–10 times, that’s a red flag. Patience allows the market’s initial emotional reaction to settle.

There is also personal risk to consider. If you are investing for retirement, a home down payment, or your children’s education, you likely cannot afford large swings. IPO stocks can move 20–40% in a single month. That kind of volatility can derail short-term financial goals. A diversified index fund averaging 7–10% annually may be less exciting, but it is far more predictable over decades.

Of course, occasionally an IPO performs well immediately and continues rising — Airbnb more than doubled on its first day, and a few IPOs keep rising for years. But building a financial plan around exceptions is dangerous. It is better to miss a few spectacular gains than to expose yourself to repeated high-risk speculation.

My advice is simple: wait at least 6–12 months, review the fundamentals, and invest only if the company fits into a diversified, long-term strategy. Investing is not a race. It is a marathon toward security.

It’s better to arrive at retirement safely than to chase every shiny new stock along the way.

Who are Rich Dad & Poor Dad? tap to expand

Rich Dad

Represents an entrepreneurial, investment-first mindset — inspired by Robert Kiyosaki's Rich Dad Poor Dad (1997). Prioritises assets, passive income, and financial independence over job security.

Poor Dad

Represents a conventional, security-focused mindset — the "get a good job, save money, avoid risk" worldview. Grounded in stability, steady income, and traditional financial wisdom.

The perspectives on this site are AI-generated illustrations of these two contrasting philosophies. They are not affiliated with Robert Kiyosaki or any related entities. Learn more.

Whose advice would you follow?

Share this debate

What do you think? (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your perspective.

More debates