Rich Dad Says
A car isn’t transportation — it’s either a tool or a trophy, and most people can’t tell the difference.
In a major city, a car is rarely a necessity — it’s usually a convenience wrapped in ego. Let’s break it down with numbers. In cities like New York, London, Toronto, or Singapore, the true cost of owning a modest car can run $800–$1,500 per month when you include payments ($400–$700), insurance ($150–$300), parking ($200–$600), gas, maintenance, and depreciation. That’s $10,000–$18,000 per year. Invest that same $1,000/month at an 8% annual return for 10 years and you’re sitting on roughly $180,000. That’s not transportation — that’s opportunity cost on wheels.
Now here’s the entrepreneurial lens: a car is only a necessity if it produces income or dramatically increases your earning power. Are you a real estate agent showing properties across town? A contractor hauling equipment? A consultant whose clients are spread across suburbs? Then the car is a business asset. It’s like a laptop — you wouldn’t call that a luxury if it helps you earn $200,000 a year. But if you’re commuting 20 minutes on a subway that costs $150/month? That car is a shiny liability.
Let’s look at scenarios. Scenario one: You live downtown, work remotely, and have Uber, trains, and grocery delivery within 10 minutes. You’d need to drive 10–15 times per month before ride-sharing even approaches the fixed cost of ownership. Scenario two: You live in Los Angeles with weak public transit and commute 45 minutes each way. In that case, the car becomes a productivity tool — it gives you 1–2 hours per day back versus patchwork transit. Time is money. If that time is used to build skills or income, the math changes.
Now here’s the uncomfortable truth: many people buy cars in cities for identity, not utility. Status, comfort, “I deserve it.” That’s emotional spending. A $50,000 SUV in Manhattan isn’t transportation — it’s parking anxiety with leather seats. Wealthy people often delay that purchase until their assets pay for it. When your investments throw off $1,500/month in passive income, then buy the car. Let the asset fund the liability.
Could there be non-financial benefits? Absolutely. Safety at night. Visiting family. Weekend freedom. But freedom is cheapest when you rent it. Rent a car for $80–$120/day when needed. Flexibility without the burden.
In a major city, a car is rarely a necessity. It’s a financial decision disguised as convenience. Treat it like a business investment — or admit it’s a luxury and make sure your assets can afford your lifestyle.
If it doesn’t make you money or save you serious time, it’s not a necessity — it’s a lifestyle choice.