Should you buy a new car or a used car right now?

Question

Rich Dad · Accepted Answer

A brand-new car loses value faster than ice cream melts in July — and you’re asking if that’s a good investment?
Let’s be blunt: a new car is almost always a liability masquerading as a status symbol. The second you drive it off the lot, it drops 10–20% in value. Within 3 years, many vehicles lose 30–40%. That’s not “ownership.” That’s financial self-sabotage on wheels. If you buy a $40,000 new car, you could watch $8,000 evaporate before your first oil change. Meanwhile, a 2–3 year old version of that same car might cost $28,000–$32,000 — and still feel practically new.
Now let’s talk opportunity cost. If you finance $40,000 at 6% over 5 years, you’ll pay roughly $6,400 in interest. Instead, imagine you bought a reliable used car for $20,000 and invested the other $20,000 in an index fund averaging 8% annually. In 10 years, that $20,000 could grow to over $43,000. That’s the difference between looking rich and becoming rich.
“But new cars have warranties and fewer repairs!” Sure. That’s the dealership’s favorite bedtime story. Modern cars regularly last 150,000–200,000 miles. A certified pre-owned Toyota, Honda, or Lexus with 30,000 miles is barely broken in. You can even buy extended warranties if you’re nervous. The key is buying smart, not shiny. Get a vehicle history report. Pay for a $150 inspection. That’s peanuts compared to the thousands you save.
Now, I’m not anti-new car — I’m anti-stupid purchase. If you’re a business owner and can legally write off depreciation under Section 179, that changes the math. If your net worth is $2 million and a $50,000 SUV represents 2.5% of your assets, fine — enjoy it. But if you’re financing 80% of it and it represents half your annual salary? You’re driving your ego instead of your equity.
Cars should serve your wealth-building machine, not compete with it. I drive assets that pay for my toys. Rental properties, businesses, dividend stocks — they buy the car. If your car payment is more than your monthly investments, you’ve got the equation backward.
Bottom line? Buy a 2–4 year old high-quality used car, keep it 8–10 years, and invest the difference. Let other people pay the depreciation tax. You build the portfolio.
Drive assets first. Drive new cars later.

Poor Dad · Answer

A car is not an investment — it’s transportation, so choose the option that protects your stability.
I understand the appeal of saving money with a used car, but you must be careful. Reliability matters, especially if you depend on your vehicle for work. Missing shifts because of breakdowns can cost far more than depreciation. A new car comes with a full manufacturer warranty — often 3 years/36,000 miles bumper-to-bumper and 5 years/60,000 miles powertrain. That predictability has value. You know your costs. You reduce surprise repair bills.
Let’s compare realistically. Suppose a new car costs $35,000 and a comparable 5-year-old model costs $20,000. Yes, you save $15,000 upfront with used. But if that used vehicle requires $2,000–$3,000 per year in maintenance — transmission issues, suspension, electronics — the savings shrink quickly. And repairs never happen at convenient times. They happen when your emergency fund is thin.
Financing also matters. New cars often qualify for lower interest rates — sometimes 0–3% promotional rates. Used cars can carry 6–9% interest. Over 60 months, that difference can add thousands in extra payments. In some cases, the payment gap between new and lightly used is surprisingly small. Always compare total cost, not just sticker price.
There’s also the psychological side. If buying new means you’ll keep the car 10–12 years, maintain it properly, and avoid the temptation to upgrade frequently, that may actually be financially disciplined. Many people buy cheap used cars every 3–4 years and end up spending more long term. Stability beats constant turnover.
However, I would strongly caution against stretching your budget. A car payment should ideally be no more than 10–15% of your monthly take-home pay. You should also have 3–6 months of expenses saved before committing. Never roll negative equity from an old loan into a new one — that’s how people stay trapped in debt cycles.
My advice? If you have stable income, strong savings, and plan to keep the vehicle long term, a modest new car can offer peace of mind. If money is tight, choose a reliable, well-inspected used vehicle and avoid luxury features.
The best car is the one that gets you to work without putting your future at risk.

Should you buy a new car or a used car right now?

Rich Dad Says

Poor Dad Says

The Bottom Line

Whose advice would you follow?

Share this debate

What do you think? (0)

More debates