Rich Dad Says
“If the service is mediocre, why are you rewarding mediocrity like it just won Employee of the Year?”
Let’s get something straight: money is a vote. Every dollar you spend tells the marketplace what behavior you approve of. If you automatically tip 20% no matter what, you’re signaling that effort doesn’t matter. Imagine investing in a stock that consistently underperforms the S&P 500 by 5% a year — would you keep pouring money into it just to be polite? Of course not. You’d reallocate capital. Same principle here.
Now, I’m not saying stiff the server because your fries weren’t crispy enough. Context matters. In the U.S., servers often make $2–$5 an hour before tips. Their livelihood depends on gratuities. But tipping 20% used to signal excellent service. Then it became standard. Now some screens start at 25%. That’s inflation of expectations without guaranteed performance. If someone forgets your drink, disappears for 30 minutes, and acts like you’re an inconvenience, rewarding that with top-tier pay doesn’t build a high-performance culture.
In business, incentives drive behavior. Salespeople earn commission because results matter. Real estate agents hustle because 3% is on the line. If every agent earned the same regardless of effort, service would plummet. Restaurants are no different. If service is truly mediocre — slow, inattentive, careless — 15% sends a clear but fair message. Not punitive. Just honest. Think of it like adjusting a performance bonus from 20% to 12% because targets weren’t met.
Now here’s the nuance: sometimes “mediocre” isn’t the server’s fault. Maybe the kitchen is slammed. Maybe they’re covering six tables because management understaffed to save on labor costs. If effort is visible but the system is broken, I still tip 20%. I reward effort, not outcomes beyond their control. That’s leadership thinking. But if it’s indifference? That’s different.
Also, remember this: if you can afford to eat out regularly, you’re already operating from abundance. On a $60 bill, the difference between 15% and 20% is $3. That won’t change your financial future. But standards matter. I tip generously for excellence — 25% or more — because I want more excellence in the world. I tip adequately, not extravagantly, for mediocrity.
Be intentional. Don’t tip out of guilt. Don’t under-tip out of ego. Tip based on value delivered.
Money is a reward system — use it to reward what you actually want more of.